Stop Sleeping On Email Marketing

Why Your Business Needs a Mailing List More Than Another Social Media Account

With social media algorithms changing faster than fashion trends, small businesses are caught in an exhausting game of catch-up. One day your Instagram posts are reaching thousands, the next day you're lucky if your own mother sees them. While social media remains crucial for visibility and attracting new clients, relying on it as your primary communication channel is like building your house on someone else's land.

The Problem with Platform Dependency

Social media platforms are rented real estate. You don't own your followers, and you're always one algorithm change—or government decision—away from losing everything. Remember when TikTok faced potential U.S. bans? Businesses that had invested years building audiences suddenly faced the possibility of starting from scratch.

Recent platform volatility examples:

  • Instagram's 2022 algorithm shift that devastated organic reach for many businesses

  • Twitter's dramatic changes under new ownership affecting user engagement

  • LinkedIn's frequent algorithm updates impacting B2B marketing strategies

Why Email Marketing Still Reigns Supreme

Your email list is owned media. Nobody can take it away from you, change the rules overnight, or decide your content isn't worth showing to people who specifically asked to see it. According to the Data & Marketing Association, email marketing delivers an average ROI of $42 for every $1 spent—that's a 4,200% return on investment.

Key advantages of email marketing:

  • Direct access: Your message lands directly in subscribers' inboxes

  • Higher engagement: Email has consistently higher engagement rates than social media

  • Personalization: Segment your audience and tailor messages to specific groups

  • Measurable results: Track open rates, click-through rates, and conversions precisely

Building Your "Warm Leads" List

The secret to successful email marketing isn't just collecting addresses—it's attracting people who genuinely want to hear from you. This means offering real value in exchange for their trust and inbox space.

Proven lead magnets that work:

  • Downloadable guides or checklists: Industry-specific templates, how-to guides, or resource lists

  • Exclusive content: Behind-the-scenes insights, early access to blog posts, or insider tips

  • Free consultations or assessments: 15-minute strategy calls or business audits

  • Discounts and promotions: Subscriber-only sales or early access to new products

Why MailerLite Is My Go-To Platform

After testing multiple platforms—Later, Mailchimp, Constant Contact, and others—I consistently recommend MailerLite for most small businesses. Here's why:

MailerLite Advantages:

  • Pricing: Free plan for up to 1,000 subscribers, then affordable scaling

  • User-friendly interface: Drag-and-drop editor that doesn't require technical skills

  • Automation capabilities: Set up welcome sequences, birthday emails, and follow-up campaigns

  • Deliverability: Strong reputation ensures your emails actually reach inboxes

Getting Started: Your Email Marketing Action Plan

  1. Choose MailerLite: Start with their free plan to test the waters

  2. Create your lead magnet: Develop one valuable resource your ideal clients would want

  3. Design your template: Keep it simple, on-brand, and mobile-friendly

  4. Set up automation: Create a welcome sequence for new subscribers

  5. Promote your list: Add signup forms to your website, social media, and business cards

The Bottom Line

Social media is great for discovery, but email marketing is where relationships deepen and sales happen. While you're chasing the latest TikTok trend, your competitors might be building direct relationships with their audience through email.

Stop sleeping on email marketing. Your future self—and your bank account—will thank you.

Ready to start building your email list but need help getting set up? Chasing Honey Consulting offers initial MailerLite setup and template design services, as well as recurring send packages to keep your email marketing running smoothly.

Additional Resources:

Courtney

Courtney is the Marketing and Events Manager at The Phoenix Taproom & Kitchen, where she combines her organizational expertise and creative vision to craft unforgettable experiences. From planning and executing seamless events to building marketing strategies that resonate with the local community, Courtney is passionate about making The Phoenix a cornerstone of Eau Claire's social and dining scene.

With a keen eye for detail and a knack for fostering meaningful connections, Courtney excels at driving brand visibility and community engagement. She thrives on creating impactful campaigns and events that celebrate the unique spirit of The Phoenix while enhancing its reputation as Eau Claire’s go-to destination for elevated food, drink, and hospitality.

Outside of her professional role, Courtney remains an advocate for animal welfare, dedicating her free time to volunteering with rescue organizations. Inspired by her own rescue dog, Margo, she’s committed to making a difference for animals in need.

Whether she’s streamlining processes at work or lending a helping hand to local rescues, Courtney approaches every opportunity with passion, purpose, and positivity.

Next
Next

New Look for Chasing Honey Consulting