What's in this post: Show
You're editing your homepage and the Heading 1 option looks way too big, so you grab Heading 3 because it's the size you want. Then you add a section below it with Heading 2, and the page never gets a Heading 1 at all. On screen, it looks great. Nobody would ever know.
Except a lot of people (and programs) would. Heading tags work as the outline of your page, and when they're out of order, screen readers and search engines get a scrambled version of your content. The good news is that the fix is quick, and you can keep the exact look you wanted.
Quick answer: Every page should have one H1 at the top that says what the page is about. Main sections use H2, and anything inside an H2 section uses H3. Never skip a level on the way down (like jumping from H1 to H3), and if a heading looks too big or too small, change the size in your site styles instead of picking a different heading level.
What Are Heading Tags?
Heading tags are labels in your website's code that mark text as a heading and tell browsers how important it is. They run from H1 (the main title) down to H6 (the smallest subheading). In Squarespace, they show up in your text block menu as Heading 1 through Heading 4.
The easiest way to think about them is a book's table of contents. The H1 is the book title. H2s are the chapters, and H3s are the sections inside each chapter. Here's what that looks like for a massage studio's services page:
H1: Massage Services in Eau Claire
H2: Deep Tissue Massage
H3: Who It Helps
H3: Pricing and Session Lengths
H2: Prenatal Massage
H3: What to Expect at Your First Visit
H2: Frequently Asked Questions
Anyone looking at that outline can tell exactly how the page is organized, without reading a single paragraph. That's the whole job of heading hierarchy.
The Simple Rules for Heading Order
You don't need to memorize anything fancy. These rules cover almost every page on a small business website:
Use one H1 per page. It goes at or near the top and says what the page is about.
Use H2 for your main sections. Most pages have several.
Use H3 for sections inside an H2. Only when an H2 section has its own smaller topics.
Don't skip levels going down. An H1 is followed by an H2, not an H3.
Jumping back up is fine. After an H3, you can start a new H2 section. That's just the next chapter.
Pick headings for their meaning, not their size. Size is a styling choice, and you can change it separately.
That last one is where most heading problems start.
Why Skipped Headings Matter for Accessibility
Screen readers are tools that read websites out loud for people who are blind or have low vision. Most screen reader users don't listen to a page from top to bottom. They pull up a list of headings and jump straight to the section they want, the same way you'd skim headings with your eyes.
This is the most common way they find information. In WebAIM's 2024 survey of screen reader users, 71.6% said they use headings to find what they need on a long page, far more than any other method.
Now picture what a screen reader announces on a page with no H1 and a Heading 3 at the top. The listener hears "heading level 3" first and assumes they've landed in the middle of something. Then they hear "heading level 2" and wonder what section they skipped. It's like opening a book to chapter 3, section 2 with no title page.
The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), which courts and regulators use as the benchmark for ADA website compliance, ask that page structure be built into the code and not only shown visually. Heading tags are a big part of that. I'm not a lawyer, and this isn't legal advice, but fixing your headings is one of the easiest accessibility wins out there.
Do Heading Tags Affect SEO?
Yes, though maybe not in the way you've heard. Google's John Mueller has said that heading order has only a slight impact on rankings, so fixing an out-of-order heading won't rocket you to the top of page one. We'd rather tell you that straight than oversell it.
Where headings help is in making your page easy to understand. Google reads your headings to figure out what each section is about, and a clear H1 tells it the main topic of the page. Think of it this way. Your website should be your best employee, and the H1 is its name tag. Without one, Google has to guess who it's talking to.
Headings matter even more for AI search. Google's AI Overviews and tools like ChatGPT pull answers from well-organized pages, and a heading like "How Much Does a Prenatal Massage Cost?" with a clear answer underneath is exactly what they look for. A tidy heading hierarchy makes your content easier for those tools to find and quote.
The Heading Mistakes We See Most Often
We see these on new client sites all the time. None of them are a big deal, and every one of them comes from a perfectly reasonable instinct.
No H1 at all. In Squarespace 7.1, regular pages don't add an H1 for you. If you didn't type one, your page doesn't have one.
An H3 above the H1 or H2. Usually a small intro line, like "Welcome to the studio," styled as a heading because it looked nice.
Choosing headings by size. Heading 1 felt too big, so the whole page got built with Heading 3 and Heading 4.
Fake headings. Bolded paragraph text that looks like a heading but isn't tagged as one, so screen readers and Google skip right past it.
Headings used for decoration. A phone number, a tagline, or a pull quote set as a heading just to make it large. Use Paragraph 1 for big text that isn't a section title.
A second H1 in a blog post. Squarespace already makes your blog post title the H1, so your post body should start with Heading 2.
How to Fix Your Heading Tags in Squarespace
This takes about 10 minutes per page once you know what you're looking for.
Check what you have. Click into any text block in the editor and highlight a heading. The format dropdown shows which level it is. For a faster look at the whole page, the free HeadingsMap browser extension or the WAVE accessibility tool lists every heading in order.
Add your H1. Near the top of each page, set the main headline to Heading 1. Make it say what the page is about, like "Brow Lamination in Eau Claire" instead of "Welcome."
Re-tag your sections. Main sections become Heading 2, and the smaller topics inside them become Heading 3.
Fix the sizes in Site Styles. If Heading 1 is now too big, go to Site Styles, then Fonts, then Headings, and adjust the size for each level. Every H1 across your site updates at once, and your pages look the way you wanted.
Swap decorative headings for paragraph styles. Taglines and big callout text can use Paragraph 1, which is larger than regular body text without being a heading.
Check blog posts. Start each post body with Heading 2, since the post title is already your H1.
Fixing the sizes in Site Styles is the part most people don't know about. It means you never have to choose between a page that looks right and a page that's built right.
A Quick Heading Check for Your Website
If you only have a few minutes today, start with your homepage and your most important service page. Ask yourself:
Is there exactly one Heading 1, near the top?
Does it say what the page is about?
Do the headings go H1, then H2, then H3, without skipping?
If you read only the headings, would the page still make sense?
That last question is a good gut check for anything you write. Clear headings help screen reader users, Google, and the visitor skimming on their phone between appointments. We cover more ways to make pages easy to skim in our post on how long a website page should be, and if you're working through accessibility fixes, our guides on accessibility and why text in images hurts your website pair nicely with this one.
Want a second set of eyes on your heading structure? Send us a message, we'd love to take a look and help get your pages organized for everyone who visits.